The Trump administration is legally required to release all files on Jeffrey Epstein this Friday, and Democrats have already promised to take action if it doesn’t, opening up the possibility of a legal dispute over the files as a senior Justice Department official confirmed that not all the documents will be made public by the deadline.
Key data
Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche stated Friday morning that while the Justice Department intends to release “hundreds of thousands” of documents by the deadline, it will release the rest of the files in the coming weeks as redactions occur, which is not permitted under federal law.
Lawmakers sharply criticized Blanche’s comments, but it is unclear when or if they might take action in response, even as Democrats threatened lawsuits if the Trump administration does not fully comply with the law.
The Epstein Records Transparency Act requires the Trump administration to make all of its records public by the end of this Friday, which marks 30 days since its enactment.
Federal law requires the Justice Department to release all of its records by the deadline, and it is only allowed to withhold or redact a few categories of information, including information that identifies victims, any data reflecting child abuse or death, classified information and information that could jeopardize a federal investigation.
Democrats and lawmakers pushing for the release of the files have stated in recent days that they could take legal action if the Trump administration does not release Epstein’s complete files by the deadline, or if they contain more redacted information than the law allows.
While the Trump administration will not prosecute itself for violating the law, a future administration could file criminal charges, and Democrats have suggested they could file civil lawsuits for any failure to comply. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., stated earlier this week that they will use “every legal, legislative and administrative resource to achieve this.”
Don’t Miss: DOJ to Release Epstein Files in Batches, Blanche Says Ahead of Initial Release Today
What have lawmakers said about the file delay?
Rep. Thomas Massie, R-Ky., a co-sponsor of the Epstein bill, posted the text of the law on X on Thursday following Blanche’s comments, noting that “all” materials must be posted within 30 days.
Schumer declared this Friday that Democrats are “working closely” with lawyers for Epstein’s victims and other attorneys “to evaluate what documents are being withheld,” but he harshly criticized the Trump administration, stating that the delay “only shows that the Department of Justice, Donald Trump and Pam Bondi are hell-bent on hiding the truth.”
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., another co-sponsor of the bill, offered a more optimistic view: “If the Department of Justice is producing real documents of interest that are not excessively redacted, and if they are clear about the timeline for their full release, that is a positive step.”
What to take into account
Federal law requires the Trump administration to release all of its information about Epstein, including documents relating to federal investigations into him and his partner Ghislaine Maxwell, flight logs related to Epstein and information about his 2019 prison death.
Upon release of the files, the government also has 15 days to publish a summary of any edits to the files, the categories of materials disclosed and withheld, and a complete list of “all government officials and politically exposed persons” who are mentioned or named in the documents.
What we know
When action could be taken against the Trump administration. Democratic lawmakers have not yet indicated whether they plan to immediately challenge the Trump administration’s decision to release the full files after Friday’s deadline, or whether they will wait to see if the documents are released in the coming weeks, as promised.
Surprising fact
Reports suggest that the Trump administration could excessively censor Epstein’s files due to a lack of time. CNN reported Thursday that Justice Department officials are “racing” to redact the files in time.
Legal documents specialists told the outlet that, as a result, officials could censor more than allowed by law, or accidentally reveal information that should have been hidden. An anonymous lawyer stated: “Either they are going to ruin it or they are going to hide information. I wouldn’t be surprised.”
We recommend: Trump Administration rushes to meet deadline to release Epstein files
Can Trump officials be prosecuted for violating the law?
Trump administration officials could face charges of violating the Epstein Act by failing to disclose all required documents, but any prosecution will take at least several years. Since any charges now would have to be brought by Trump’s Justice Department — which is almost certainly unwilling to prosecute itself — any indictments would have to be brought by a future Democratic administration in the coming years.
Lawmakers who drafted the legislation said charges can still be filed years later without violating the statute of limitations. “This is a law and it will last forever,” Massie declared in a video posted to X on Thursday.
What can Democrats do if Epstein files are withheld?
Democrats suggested they are considering filing civil lawsuits to challenge any attempts by the Trump administration to withhold files or information under the law, including challenging specific redactions, as well as any broader refusal to release the files.
Schumer stated during a press conference this week that if Epstein’s files contain more redacted texts than necessary, Democrats will “first argue that… much of the redacted material need not be” and “will be prepared to argue that in court.”
Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., also suggested to NBC News on Wednesday that Democrats could force Trump officials to testify before Congress about any noncompliance.
Key context
Congress passed the Epstein Files Transparency Act almost unanimously in November, after the Justice Department announced over the summer that it would not voluntarily release any more files, sparking public outrage.
While the government turned over some of its Epstein files to the House Oversight Committee in response to a subpoena, Democrats repeatedly accused the Trump administration of intentionally delaying the release of the files and perpetuating a “cover-up” of the files, as the Justice Department largely released materials that were already public while continuing to conceal other files.
The Trump administration denied any wrongdoing and insisted that its priority is to protect Epstein’s victims, although many of them pushed for the files to be released with redacted information to protect their identities.
President Donald Trump, who was friends with Epstein from the 1980s to the early 2000s but was never accused of wrongdoing, denounced the Epstein files as a “hoax,” though he ultimately encouraged Republicans to back the Transparency Act when it became clear the legislation would pass anyway, and he signed it into law.
This article was originally published in Forbes US
Do you like to get informed through Google News? Follow our Showcase to have the best stories